The notion that the South did not really differ from the North proved powerful among historians. The army officer assigned to organize logistics for the reunion held at Vicksburg predicted the gathering would promote patriotism "and that is what we need in war time" Evening Post, Oct.
Bonded by the common danger they face in battle, they become a band of brothers whose mutual dependence and mutual support in combat create the cohesion necessary to function as a fighting unit. Isaac Shoemaker, diary, Feb. The War Years, Valley of the Shadow. Gazing at Bloody Lane where, inseveral Union assaults were brutally repulsed before they finally broke through, he marveled, "You couldn't get American soldiers today to make an attack like that.
On May 20,James Gardner, one of Mathew Brady's field photographers, recorded this image of Union soldiers who had been wounded earlier that month in the Battle of the Wilderness near Fredericksburg, Va.
Jimerson writes that the North understood the war as a "holy crusade," fought to the tune of the "Battle Hymn of the Republic. The Vietnam War made some understandings of the Civil War experience untenable.
Cambridge University Press, In much of the literature on this subject, one might get the impression that such a role did not exist. Stephen Compton did not discuss slavery as a motivation but did mention African Americans in a manner that demonstrated his racial views. For all his prodigious research, Wiley could find only superficial differences between Confederates and Yankees.
Significantly, their letters were also uncensored by military authorities, and are uniquely frank in their criticism and detailed in their reports of marches and battles, relations between officers and men, political debates, and morale. Please contact mpub-help umich.
Wickham, commander of the famous st Airborne Division in the s and subsequently Army Chief of Staff, once visited Antietam battlefield.
Unquestionably, the North had a tremendous advantage over the South. Where the words end and the blank pages begin can mark a moving realization for the researcher comfortably seated in a modern archives.
We fought once and could do it again" Oct. Each side used the founding fathers to justify going to war with the other.
He also described the declining health of his regiment, many afflicted with measles, fevers, colds and coughs. As the memorials, ceremonies, celebrations and activities draw to a close this year, it leaves many to wonder if the Civil War will continue to hold the interest of historians beyond.
McPherson goes on to examine soldiers' writings to discover why they stayed in service when times were bleak, such as Union soldiers after Fredericksburg and Second Bull Run and Confederates after the triple whammy of Gettysburg, Vicksburg, and Chattanooga/5().
Sierra Moses American History (HIS) November 30, Reading Assignment #4 Study questions for Why Soldiers Went to War By James M.
How did the war affect the popularity of slavery in the south? It is to this question--why did they fight--that James McPherson, America's preeminent Civil War historian, now turns his attention.
He shows that, contrary to what many scholars believe, the soldiers of the Civil War remained powerfully convinced of the ideals for which they fought throughout the conflict.
To find the wellsprings of Civil War valor, James McPherson has read diaries and at least 25, letters of 1, Civil War soldiers. "It would be close to the truth," he writes, "to say that Civil War soldiers wrote" For Cause and Comrades."They articulated their motives for fighting far above my poor power to add or detract" (vii).
By Clayton Butler. The Civil War Trust's own Clayton Butler recently had the opportunity to sit down with one the most distinguished scholars in the field of Civil War history – Dr.
James McPherson, Princeton University's George Henry Davis Professor of American History. War historians, James M. McPherson, to examine what it was that motivated Civil War soldiers many historians have traditionally believed that as the war went on, soldiers became embittered soldiers in WWII and Vietnam were draftees or professional soldiers while.
civil war.” For. For Cause and Comrades War in. For Cause and.Why soldiers went to war james mcpherson